Be Number One Somewhere: What Hertz, Avis and Enterprise Teach Nigerian SMEs About Winning a Crowded Market

  • Home
  • Be Number One Somewhere: What Hertz, Avis and Enterprise Teach Nigerian SMEs About Winning a Crowded Market
Be Number One Somewhere: What Hertz, Avis and Enterprise Teach Nigerian SMEs About Winning a Crowded Market
November 11, 2026

Leaders take far more than their share, but you do not have to be the biggest in the whole market. You have to be the obvious first choice for someone specific.

Executive Summary

In many markets, the leader takes a share of rewards far out of proportion to its lead, and the rest fight over what is left.[1][2][3] Nigeria has about 39.65 million micro, small and medium businesses, so standing out matters more than ever.[4] But the research and real business history point to a hopeful answer: you do not have to beat everyone, you have to lead somewhere specific. This article explains why the gap between first place and the rest is so wide, where that idea stops working, how a car rental company went from fifth place to first by choosing a niche, and gives you a seven-step plan to find your own.[7][8]

Introduction

Three-quarters to the leader. The authors of Play Bigger looked at about 8,000 venturebacked US technology companies and picked out 35 that had become the clear leader of their market (what they call a “category king”). In those markets, the leader took roughly 76% of the total value. Every other company in the market had to share what was left: less than a quarter.[6

Read that again, because it should bother you. The leader does not take a slightly bigger slice than the runner-up. It takes about three times as much as all its rivals put together. (A caution: this is a finding about venture-backed technology, not about every market, and later we will look at where it does not apply.)

Now bring it home. Nigeria has about 39.65 million micro, small and medium businesses, and only about 3.1% of them are small or medium-sized; the rest are micro businesses.[4] Whatever you sell, someone nearby sells it too. So what does a founder do?

Meet Amaka and Tunde. Amaka runs a shop in Lagos that sells “everything for events”: decor, catering trays, party packs, whatever customers ask for. Tunde runs a small delivery firm in Ibadan, but he does one thing only: temperature-controlled deliveries for restaurants and caterers. Five years on, Amaka is busy and tired and competes on price with a hundred similar shops. Tunde has a waiting list, charges more, and restaurants call him first. Same effort, different position. This article is about how to be Tunde.

What Happened?

The idea has a long history. In 1981 the economist Sherwin Rosen explained why top performers earn far more than people who are only slightly less talented. He pointed to two forces: one performance can be enjoyed by many people at almost no extra cost, and buyers will pay more than proportionally for the very best, because second-best is a poor substitute.[1] Technology widens the effect, since a recording or an app can serve millions.

Advantage compounds. In 1968 the sociologist Robert Merton described the “Matthew effect”, named after the biblical idea that those who have will be given more, showing how recognition and rewards flow disproportionately to those who are already known.[2] In business terms: customers, talent, partners and investors tend to go where others have already gone.

It spread beyond stars. Robert Frank and Philip Cook popularised the term “winner-take-all” in their 1995 book. A reference entry on the idea notes that small differences in performance can create very large differences in reward, and that these markets can be wasteful when rivals pour resources into out-competing each other.[3] Ries and Trout made a marketing version of the same point: it is better to be first in a market than to be better, and markets tend to become races between two main players.[11]

Even Jack Welch built a strategy on it. His famous rule at General Electric was to be number one or number two in a market or fix, sell or close. One published summary of the Slater biography quotes him: “When you’re number four or five in a market, when number one sneezes, you get pneumonia.”[10]

But there is a twist: the Rule of Three. A study of more than 160 industries by Uslay, Altintig and Winsor found that mature industries tend to be dominated by three generalist firms, and that both specialists and generalists outperform firms “stuck in the middle”.[5] Read that carefully. It does not say only number one wins. It says the weakest position is being a middle-of-the-road business with no clear identity.

Why This Matters

If Nigeria had only a few businesses in each sector, this would be an academic discussion. But the last national survey counted about 39.65 million MSMEs, contributing an estimated 46.31% of GDP.[4] That means most owners compete in crowded markets where customers can switch easily. In that environment, being “quite good at everything” is the most expensive strategy there is: you spend heavily on marketing to be noticed, you compete on price, and your best customers have no particular reason to stay.

Money is also tight. The EFInA 2026 survey found that only about 10% of Nigerian adults use formal credit, and that the share of formal loans taken to run or grow a business fell from 40.2% in 2023 to 34.3% in 2026, while the share taken just to cope with everyday expenses rose.[12][13] Lenders have limited appetite and limited time, which makes a clear, specific, easy-to-understand business more attractive than a vague one. (That last point is our view as a lender, not a survey finding.)

A tale of two car rental companies

History gives us a perfect pair of examples. In 1962, Avis was number two to Hertz and was losing money. Its agency, Doyle Dane Bernbach, turned second place into a promise: “We try harder.” Within a year, Avis went from losing $3.2 million to earning $1.2 million, and the market share gap between Hertz and Avis narrowed from 61% against 29% in 1963 to 49% against 36% by 1966.[7] So a strong number two is possible, and Avis got there by being clear about what made it different.

But Avis never caught Hertz.[7] Who did? Enterprise. Founded in 1957 in St. Louis, it began by serving a segment the airport giants largely ignored: people who needed a replacement car because theirs was being repaired or was stolen, often arranged through insurance adjusters, in the home city away from airports.[8] In the early 1990s it was only the fifth-largest rental chain. By 1996 it had passed Hertz as the largest in the United States by fleet size and number of offices.[8] By 2012, Hertz itself was opening hundreds of neighbourhood locations, following a similar model.[9]

Enterprise did not start by fighting Hertz at the airport. It chose a place where it could be the first choice, grew there until it was dominant, and then the whole market came to it. That is the lesson: be number one somewhere.

What SMEs Should Do

Here is a seven-step plan you can start this week. Grab a notebook.

  • Step 1: List who you actually serve. Write down your last 30 to 50 customers or invoices. Group them by type (for example restaurants, schools, event planners, farmers, other businesses).
  • Step 2: Score each group. Give each group a mark from 1 to 5 on four questions: Is it profitable? Do they buy again? Do we do this better than competitors? Is it hard for others to copy our approach? Tick the one or two groups with the highest totals.
  • Step 3: Write your position sentence. Complete this: “We are the first choice for ______ who need ______ in ______.” Tunde’s is: “We are the first choice for restaurants and caterers in Ibadan who need cold deliveries that arrive on time.” If your sentence is longer than one breath, narrow it.
  • Step 4: Prove it. Collect three customer stories, publish your delivery times, show before and after results, and make referrals easy. Trust is the currency of leadership.
  • Step 5: Go deeper before wider. Add a related service or a neighbouring customer group only after you are clearly the preferred option in your first niche. Enterprise went from home-city replacement rentals to the whole market, not the other way round.
  • Step 6: Track four numbers every month. Share of your niche (even a rough estimate), repeat customer rate, referral rate, and gross margin. If these rise, your position is working.
  • Step 7: Fund the focus. A niche usually requires specific stock, equipment, staff or training. Work out what it costs and how quickly it pays back before you borrow. Our loan calculator can show you the monthly repayment on different tenors.

A worked example (illustrative numbers only). Suppose Tunde’s general delivery work earns a 12% margin and is won mostly on price, while his cold-chain work for caterers earns 22% and brings referrals. On every ₦1 million of work, the first leaves him ₦120,000 and the second ₦220,000. If he shifts his time, vehicles and marketing toward the second group, his income rises without working harder, and each satisfied caterer makes the next one easier to win. These figures are invented to show the logic, so replace them with your own from Steps 1 and 2.

A quick test for your niche. It is probably a good one if (a) customers can describe you in one sentence, (b) at least a few customers asked for you by name, (c) you can name the three competitors that matter, and (d) your margin in this group is higher than your average.

Risks to Watch

  • Not every market is winner-take-all. Where customers value local presence or personal relationships, such as many restaurants, salons and repair services, many firms can thrive side by side. Do not force a leadership strategy onto a market that does not reward it.
  • A niche that is too small. Being number one in a tiny market can still leave you with too little income. Check that enough customers exist and can pay.
  • One-customer dependence. If one buyer is 70% of your niche revenue, you do not have a niche, you have a client. Keep at least five meaningful customers.
  • Copycats and giants. Hertz did eventually follow Enterprise into neighbourhoods.[9] Keep improving, and keep your relationships personal.
  • The middle trap. The research warns against being “stuck in the middle”, neither a scale leader nor a clear specialist.[5] If you cannot say what you are best at, customers cannot either.
  • Mistaking big for good. Biggest is not the same as most profitable. A business with a smaller but loyal, high-margin niche can be healthier than a larger one fighting on price.

Opportunities

Digital payments make niches visible. In October 2026, Moniepoint’s CEO argued that lenders should judge businesses by how they generate and manage money rather than primarily by the collateral they can pledge, because transaction data can reveal firms with steady revenue.[12] A business with a clear niche tends to have steady, repeating transactions, which makes it easier to evaluate.

Supply chains reward specialists. Large buyers tend to keep, and recommend, suppliers who deliver reliably in a narrow category. For those suppliers, a steady flow of confirmed purchase orders is evidence of a strong niche position.

Nigeria is large and varied. Regional, sector and community needs differ widely, from agroprocessing to logistics to digital services. Each pocket has room for someone to be the obvious first choice.

Authority compounds. Rosen’s and Merton’s ideas work in your favour once you start winning:

every referral, case study and repeat customer makes the next one easier.[1][2]

CreditPRO Insight

We meet business owners at every stage, and the ones who are easiest to support rarely have the biggest premises or the widest range. They have a clear answer to the question: who do you serve, and why do they choose you? Clarity makes it easier for us to understand your cash cycle, assess repayment capacity and structure financing that fits your business.

It also shapes how we think about our own work. Products like LPO finance and invoice discounting are built for businesses with confirmed orders and invoices, a specific need rather than a general promise. When you are ready to fund your niche, start with our loan calculator to test the numbers, then explore our loan offerings or speak to our team through the contact page. If this way of thinking about your business appeals to you, you may also enjoy our earlier piece on thinking smaller before you grow bigger.

Final Thoughts

The research says leaders often take far more than their share. History says you do not need to be the biggest to win. Avis proved that a clear second-place identity can pay. Enterprise proved that a niche leader can become the market leader. Both started by deciding exactly who they were for.

You do not have to beat everyone. You have to be the obvious first choice for someone. Write your position sentence today, test it on three customers this week, and be Tunde.

Sources & References

https://www.fundinguniverse.com/company-histories/enterprise-rent-a-car-company-history

  • News-Tribune, “Hertz targets Enterprise, move into neighborhoods”, 26 July 2012.

https://www.newstribune.com/news/2012/jul/26/hertz-targets-enterprise-move-neighborhoods

https://www.nigeriahousingmarket.com/news/nigeria-lending-cash-flow-collateral-moniepoint

  • ThisDay, “Report: Nigerians Turning to Survival Loans as Consumption Borrowing Jumps”, 5

October 2026. https://www.thisdaylive.com/2026/10/05/report-nigerians-turning-to-survival-loansas-consumption-borrowing-jumps/



About the Author
Anthony Jiboye is the Head of Growth and Customer Experience at CreditPRO Finance Company Limited. With a proven track record in driving business expansion, customer retention strategies, and service excellence, Anthony leads CreditPRO’s growth initiatives to deliver seamless, customer-centric financial solutions. He is passionate about scaling innovative financial products, enhancing user journeys, and empowering businesses across Nigeria to access reliable funding and growth opportunities.